Victoria’s Secret Caves, Catalog Goes Green

With holiday shopping in full swing, some major brands have made announcements that they’re embracing the environmental cause and that paper used in catalogs will come from environmentally friendly, sustainably harvested sources.In late November, Williams-Sonoma announced that it will begin sourcing more than 90 percent of the paper used in the company’s seven catalogs (Williams-Sonoma, Pottery Barn, Pottery Barn Bed and Bath, Pottery Barn Kids, PBteen, west elm and Williams-Sonoma Home) from sources certified by the Forest Stewardship Council, writes Environmental Leader.

Just this week, Limited Brands (parent company of Victoria’s Secret, Express, Bath & Body Works, and The Limited) signed a new forest policy that says it will no longer work with suppliers who source from the Rocky Mountain Foothills near Hinton, Alberta, and will no longer use suppliers who source paper from caribou habitat in Canada unless it has been certified by the Forest Stewardship Council. Victoria’s Secret alone sends out more than 1 million catalogs per day.

What’s not clear is whether these green overtures will improve relationships with their consumers. In August, sixty-four percent of respondents in a study by Landor Associates couldn’t name a green brand. Even worse, fifty-one percent who claimed to be in the green camp couldn’t point to one.

What is clear is that ForestEthics and its campaign against the catalog industry are working. It was two years ago that the group launched the campaign against Victoria’s Secret.

Don’t expect ForestEthics to rest on its laurels with this win. Its Christmas-themed naughty and nice list from last year points to a few companies, such as Dell, Williams Sonoma, and Norm Thompson Outfitters, that are in the green camp. But more than 15 big brands like Sears, J.Crew, and Eddie Bauer are not. ForestEthics list states: “J. Crew just doesn’t care. Their catalogs come straight from Endangered Forests, leaving behind ruined homes for the reindeer (caribou), bears, and people too! Nothing but coal for naughty J. Crew.”

As that kind of messaging heats up, other catalog companies will most likely follow Victoria’s lead, the Financial Post reports (via ForestEthics). The Victoria’s Secret announcement “creates a precedent that can be quite dangerous to the industry,” Ilan Vertinsky, director of the forest economics and policy analysis research unit at the University of British Columbia said. “It doesn’t take a large group or a very powerful group to create enough disturbance to a buyer that the buyer is going to have the incentive to switch.”